I have two second grade gifted girls. The younger one was whole grade accelerated. They both go to our local public school and it's been an amazing journey for our family. I also have a 22 year old son. He was tested in fifth grade and his school told me he was gifted. I did what I think most parents do, I said to myself, "oh, how nice. Well, now the school knows and they'll take care of him." In my defense I didn't have the benefit of a robust internet that we now have to look up information. But to my son's discredit, it didn't even occur to me to find out what the school or state policy was on educating gifted children, what being gifted means, and if his needs were any different than his same age peers. I didn't try to talk to a single teacher, parent, or look at a single book. He paid the price for this later, always struggling to fit in and me not understanding why he couldn't seem to finish his homework, why he was so dramatic and sensitive, and why he was not interested in school by the time he reached high school.
I don't mean to tell you that you had better find out about these kids or your doomed. Every child is different and not every parent is as naive as I was. Additionally, we had extenuating circumstances that muddied the water and confused the issues. It was easy for me to deflect any issue onto his difficulties adjusting to the divorce.
I like to think I'm older and wiser now. Maybe I'm just older! But when my youngest started to retreat into herself in kindergarten and her personality began to disappear I knew it was time to do something. Our pediatrician recommended that we join the Connecticut Association of Gifted Children, I did. I also joined the National Association of Gifted Children and Advocating for Gifted And Talented New York. Then I watched and waited for a volunteer opportunity to arise so that I could connect with other parents and hopefully find some resources. Katie Augustyn, president of CT Association of Gifted Children came to the rescue. By connecting with her through volunteering for their (FAUBLOUS) Minds in Motion events, she led me to the Hoagies Gifted website which opened Pandora's box for me.
I'm a reader and researcher. I immersed myself in the research and articles and books and was completely captivated by what I was learning. I've come to understand that not everybody operates this way. Many people find the prospect of having to pour over this much information overwhelming at best and a turn-off at worst.
In my excitement I became over-zealous. I copied packets of articles for the other parents of gifted children in my children's grades and for their teachers. I started emailing links and articles almost every day. Nobody responded. I didn't get it. I thought this was the coolest stuff I had ever read! The other parents thought I was a nut job. My one cause for hope was the school principal who stopped me in the hall one day nearly leaping out of his shoes, "isn't this exciting?!" he exclaimed. "I can't stop reading it!"
I'm still really turned on by the research around gifted people. I'm learning to put my passion to use in places it will make a difference. The reality is that New York State legislation does nothing for gifted children. That's why the vast majority of teachers and administrators don't know anything about gifted children, any more than I did when my fifth grade son tested in the gifted range; oh, isn't that nice. I've had to reach out beyond the parents in my local school district. I've worked with local politicians, the school board, the president of the teachers union. I'm working with gifted organizations, and now starting this resource blog to connect families with local resources and each other. In addition I'm going to develop art programs for families of gifted children which they can access online.
I would love for our local public school to know what to do with these children, to ability group them, to give them a teacher certified in gifted education and provide them with stimulating, deep educational choices that are right for each of them. And I will keep pushing for that for my children because that is in their best interest. But I know the problem exists on a broader level and so I'll work on a broader level, and pace myself. I still feel a little isolated in my community. But we've not yet lived here two years. I hope to meet some of you soon.
Kind Regards,
Kate Vrijmoet
P.S. Here is a link to an interesting article I came upon this morning! You'll have to cut and paste it into your browser address bar:
http://www.newswise.com/articles/view/549632/?sc=rsln
Synopsis: Gifted Children Shape Personalities According to Social Stigma
[Newswise Mon, 02 Mar 2009]
Gifted youths already know what they want to be when they grow up, but when they are asked why they made their choices, they are not able to explain. Society identifies the gifted child with high intelligence and is often hasty to identify this intelligence with specific subjects, especially exact or prestigious sciences. The maturing children are quick to adopt this identy, renouncing the...
Everytime I read an article, I can definitely relate. We have 5 children. The oldest a boy who is 15 and a 9th grader. He has been identified as gifted in several areas Art where very little is offered. Music - Vocal where he participated in the Hudson Valley Youth Chorale that travelled to Budapest Hungary during elementary school until it was not cool to be in Chorus as a boy. Luckily he took an accelerated class in voice in middle school. And is loving chorus at the high school level. Thank God for All County music opportunities. He shines. He had to choose between music or sports and Athletics won out.
ReplyDeleteMath where he waivers because it's not cool to be a Math geek. He's in accelerated Science classes but he is an auditory learner. If he has a great teacher/lecturer he loves it. He is very talented academically but does not love books/textbooks. How he memorizes and remembers everything, I don't know. He has lots of interest in Social Studies but why does Math and Science always win out on the accelerated track. He gets very frustrated with certain teachers. He is also gifted in sports football, wrestling and baseball. He has decided he is going to be a helicopter pilot as a freshman in high school. When I ask why he just knows... Luckily he is doing well socially he fits in because of being well rounded. Is he truly meeting his potential? School and Life have come easily to him. He is just now beginning to be challenged. He is very organized but does he really know how to study. He only wants to do what he enjoys. This article suggest that they may automatically choose the military. Is that the best option just because it is easily laid out? Does it give him an identity as being a young man, talented, manly, and not under the scrutiny of appearing to be a geek. How come it is not cool to be intellectually stimulated? How come they don't look forward to being considered really smart? He seems to want to hide his intelligence. Is it to be popular and to not stand out in an uncool way?
I know I am rambling... But I'm sure there is another mom out there strattling these two worlds. Sometimes I just wish our children were just average. Thanks for sharing the articles. Eventually I'm sure I will feel more focused, right now I'm just sorting out my feelings for each of the children. Thanks for being on the other end.
I echo your sentiments Kate in your wish for abilty grouped classes for gifted children....with STIMULATING lessons....
ReplyDeleteI would love to see ALL children benefit from more exciting and stimulating instruction....
My older son is in Kindergarten now...public...and is CRAVING soooooo much more! How can we expect our gifted children to stay motivated and excited to learn when they are given worksheets that they could complete 4 years earlier? My toddler actually did my kindergartener's homework yesterday with 100% accuracy!!!
I have met with the school on several occasions...even requested a collaboration with his two teachers, the school psychologist and the Principal....which has been somewhat helpful...but he still comes home with what he thinks of as "baby work"....I modify the homework to make it more exciting....but sorting words that start with the letter N when the kid is reading on an 8th grade reading level with full comprehension??? That is hard to enforce....
The only "modification" that he is getting is the opportunity to go to the second grade reading lessons...the books are too easy...but the content is appropriate for his emotional age....sorry to babble.....We have a long road ahead of us and this year was just a glimpse at what is to come.
The fact that he acts out does not make advocating for him easy...but he is coming along socially....
Diana-
ReplyDeleteThough my school age boy is much younger...we are definitely finding our share of hurdles!
Hilary,
ReplyDeleteI believe we are from the same county. Ulster
I am beginning to start an AGATE group in Ulster County. Would love to have you participate. I am going to the next AGATE meeting down in Westchester/Putnam if you would like to car pool let me know.
I also agree with both of your desires to have ability grouping in the public schools. In our elementary they keep including spec ed children and expect our advanced/gifted children to be their tutors. This works for my older daughter sometimes but does not work at all for my younger daughter. I wish we could group children with high academic ability from the whole district and bus them together. Our school is so small they are busing 30% or greater special ed in. Why can't they bus the talented and gifted in? Pull out some and Push in others. Even the twice exceptional students could get all of their needs met.
My daughters need more peers who enjoy reading above their grade level one or two grade levels. I wish our school would accelerate them also. We make them come to school early and stay late. Why can't they differentiate and teach them at their levels and abilities during the hours of 9 - 3. I'm beginning to sound frustrated. I want to see creativity and opportunity abound for our children. Keep sharing.... and advocating... What we are doing here is making a difference.... We must stay positive. Thank you all for listening.
Fabfive